REQUEST YOUR FREE QUOTE TODAY (800) 365-1382

When it comes to protecting your home’s exterior and keeping its value intact, choosing between vinyl and aluminum gutters is a big decision. It’s not just about the initial cost—the material you pick can have long-term effects on the structural integrity and overall upkeep of your property.

The Pouring Debate Between Vinyl vs Aluminum Gutters

Choosing the perfect gutter material for your home isn’t as simple as flipping a coin between vinyl and aluminum. Each option has its own set of pros and cons that you need to carefully consider.

Vinyl (PVC) Gutters

Vinyl, also known as PVC (polyvinyl chloride), is a popular choice for homeowners seeking an affordable and low-maintenance gutter solution. Vinyl gutters are made from a durable plastic material that is resistant to rust, dents, and cracks. They are lightweight and easy to install, often without the need for specialized tools or sealants. Vinyl gutters can be found at many home improvement stores and online retailers, making them a convenient option for DIY projects or professional installations.

Pros

  • Affordability: Vinyl gutters are one of the most affordable gutter options, costing between $3 and $6 per linear foot, which is significantly less than other materials like aluminum, stainless steel, and copper.
  • Lightweight: Vinyl gutters are made from a lightweight material, weighing just 0.3-0.5lbs per foot, making it easier to install compared to heavier gutter options, especially for DIYers.
  • Color Variety: Vinyl gutters are available in a wide range of color options such as brown, grey, white, and tan, allowing homeowners to choose a hue that complements their home’s aesthetic.

Cons

  • Limited Size Options: Vinyl gutters are typically only available in standard gutter sizes of 4-6 inches, which may not always fit the specific needs of a home.
  • Thermal Issues: Vinyl gutters can become brittle in cold temperatures and warp in hot temperatures, which can compromise their structural integrity.
  • Color Fading: Due to prolonged exposure to sunlight, the color of vinyl gutters can begin to fade from the UV rays after 5-10 years.
  • Durability Concerns: Vinyl gutters are less durable than other materials, and are prone to cracking/breaking. They may not last as long as metal gutters, typically around 15-20 years.
  • Seam and Joint Issues: Vinyl gutters are made up of multiple sections that are joined together, creating potential weak points where leaks can occur over time.

Aluminum Gutters

Aluminum has long been the preferred choice for professional gutter installers, and it’s easy to see why. Aluminum gutters are known for their excellent rigidity and durability, providing a reliable and long-lasting solution for protecting your home.

Pros

  • On-Site Design: Aluminum gutters can be custom-designed and fabricated on-site to fit the specific dimensions of your home, ensuring a perfect fit.
  • Durability and Low-Maintenance: Aluminum gutters are highly durable, resistant to corrosion, and require minimal maintenance over their long lifespan of 20 years or more.
  • Wind Resistance: Aluminum gutters are sturdy and can withstand high winds, making them a reliable choice in areas prone to severe weather.
  • Resale Value: Aluminum gutters are considered a valuable home improvement that can increase the resale value of your property.

Cons

  • Higher Upfront Cost: Aluminum gutters are generally more expensive than other options like vinyl gutters, costing around 30% more, averaging $6-$12+ per linear foot for labor and materials, on a standard single-family home.
  • Requires Professional Install: Aluminum gutters are heavier than vinyl, making them more challenging for DIY installation and requiring professional expertise and equipment.

Why You Can’t Mix Aluminum and Vinyl Gutters

When you’re trying to decide between vinyl and aluminum gutters, there’s one thing you absolutely need to keep in mind: never mix the two materials in the same gutter system. Trust me, it’s a recipe for disaster.

When aluminum and vinyl are in direct contact with each other and exposed to moisture, a process called galvanic corrosion occurs. This is an electrochemical reaction where the dissimilar metals begin corroding each other and breaking down.

Any professional gutter installer will tell you to never mix different gutter materials. It’s just asking for trouble and expensive repairs down the road—make sure you stick with the same material throughout your home’s exterior.

Why Aluminum Gutters “Rain” Supreme

When it comes to gutter system quality and longevity, aluminum is simply in a league of its own compared to vinyl. Sure, vinyl gutters might seem like a good idea if you’re trying to save a few bucks upfront, but trust me, investing in aluminum gutters is the smart move in the long run.

These things are built to last, and I mean really last. We’re talking 20 years or more with proper maintenance. The tough, corrosion-resistant construction of aluminum means your gutters will keep doing their job of channeling water away from your home for decades. Bottom line? If you want a truly low-maintenance, resilient gutter solution built to last, aluminum gutters are well worth the added investment over vinyl.

Just Remember, You Get What You Pay for

For major home improvements like gutter systems, it’s important to remember that the old saying “you get what you pay for” really holds true. While vinyl gutters may seem more affordable upfront, the money you save could end up going towards premature replacements down the line. In contrast, investing in high-quality aluminum gutters provides peace of mind, knowing that your home’s exterior will stay protected and looking great for years to come.

Your new gutters should be a smart, long-term investment, not a regrettable compromise. When it comes to safeguarding your home, choosing the right gutter installation company (like Aerotech, the gutter experts with over 30 years of expertise) can make all the difference. Contact us today for all of your gutter needs!